‘Uniquely reprehensible’: No parole for 35 years for Calgary man in triple murder

CALGARY — A Calgary man who admitted to slitting his girlfriend’s throat and, days later, stabbing to death his mother and stepfather must serve 35 years before he can apply for parole.

Dustin Duthie, 27, pleaded guilty last month to second-degree murder in the 2018 deaths of Taylor Toller and Shawn Boshuk, and first-degree murder in the death of Alan Pennylegion. 

The crimes carry an automatic life sentence, but Justice Glen Poelman agreed with a Crown recommendation to increase the minimum 25-year parole ineligibility period due to the level of violence.

“He committed three consecutive murders of members of his intimate circle, each exceeding in brutality and violence the one before it,” Poelman said Thursday.

“The callous abandonment of Ms. Toller’s body for five days followed by the murders of two more family members are uniquely reprehensible.”

An agreed statement of facts said Toller, Duthie’s girlfriend of five years, was last seen on video footage from outside her condo unit about 4 a.m. on July 26, 2018. Duthie was captured on the video leaving the condo alone about an hour later. 

Five days later, police found the 24-year-old woman with her throat slit and “tucked into her bed as if she was asleep.”

On the same day she was discovered, the court document said Duthie stabbed Boshuk, his mother, six times in their home and covered her with a plastic sheet. 

It said Pennylegion witnessed Duthie cleaning his mother’s blood in the kitchen and Duthie attacked his stepfather, stabbing him eight times. 

The judge said Duthie deserved some credit for entering a guilty plea to spare the victims’ families a lengthy trial, and he did appear to have genuine remorse.

But Poelman said that’s not enough to lessen the parole period.

“The adverse considerations are what appear to be a cold, methodical approach to following up his murders with showering, some attempts to clean the scenes of evidence and a demonstrated capability of impulsive and violent conduct,” said the judge. 

“The effect of this killing spree on friends and family of the victims is incalculable.”

Duthie earlier apologized to the families of the victims during the sentencing hearing, saying what he did was “inexcusable.” 

The judge said Duthie is still a young man and could eventually be released.

“This is not necessarily what the cases call a whole life sentence. He has a prospect of being eligible to apply for parole during his lifetime.”

This report by The Canadian Press was first published April 8, 2021. 

— Follow @BillGraveland on Twitter

Bill Graveland, The Canadian Press